ReviewCircle · Community

Community Rules

The practical guide to reviewing safely and honestly on ReviewCircle. These rules are part of our Terms of Use.

1. Why these rules matter

ReviewCircle exists so authors can help each other get honest, thoughtful reviews. Please take a few minutes to read this page — following it protects your books, your reviews and your accounts on every review platform.

  • These rules form part of our Terms of Use, which every member accepts at registration.
  • Questions? Ask the ReviewCircle Assistant or write to reviews@1ib.net before you start — it saves you trouble later.

2. Respect each platform's guidelines

Amazon, Goodreads, Barnes & Noble and Kobo each have their own community guidelines. You are responsible for following them on your own account.

  • Meet the platform's account requirements before reviewing there (for example, Amazon may require a minimum spend on your customer account in the relevant marketplace).
  • Review only books you have actually read. Reviews exist to help readers, not to collect Tokens.
  • Write about the book itself — no seller, shipping, pricing or availability comments.
  • No advertising, repetitive text, spam or symbol art.
  • No private information about yourself or the author.
  • No hate speech, profanity, harassment or medical cure claims.

3. No review swapping — ever

Review platforms prohibit reciprocal reviews and reviews from people close to the author. ReviewCircle is built as a one-way system to keep you safe.

  • Once one member has reviewed another member's book, our system permanently hides all books between those two accounts in both directions.
  • Do not review books by friends, family, business partners or anyone financially connected to you — and don't let them review yours.
  • Do not review books that directly compete with your own.
  • Never arrange reviews outside the platform, and never make your rating depend on how your own book is rated.
  • Using several review clubs at the same time can undermine these protections. Our safeguards only cover activity on ReviewCircle.

4. Honest reviews only

  • Your rating is your own. No author may request, expect or reward a positive rating.
  • Constructive criticism is welcome and is never penalised.
  • Do not selectively drop books just to avoid leaving a critical review — that distorts the picture for readers.
  • Thoughtful, descriptive reviews that discuss the book's content are what make this community valuable.

5. Slow and steady protects your account

Platforms use automated systems to detect unusual activity. Giving or receiving many reviews in a short time can trigger restrictions, review removals or account suspension — which are hard to reverse.

  • Keep a natural pace. As a guideline, post no more than a handful of Amazon reviews per week.
  • ReviewCircle limits active library slots per book so reviews arrive gradually.
  • If a platform removes your reviews or books for violating its guidelines, we may restrict or suspend your ReviewCircle account.

6. How a review works, step by step

  • Pick a book from the library and reserve it on ReviewCircle before you start reading, so nobody else takes the slot.
  • Get your copy as offered by the author (a free reading copy, a library loan or your own purchase). External costs are not reimbursed.
  • Read the whole book and take notes.
  • Post your honest review on the platform you chose (Amazon, Goodreads, Barnes & Noble or Kobo), in the place that platform intends for it.
  • Submit the link to your published review on ReviewCircle. Amazon can take several days to publish — please don't post the same review twice.
  • Once confirmed, you earn 1 Token. Use 1 Token to list one of your own books.

7. Listing your book

Think of the library as a single display stand in a bookshop: one copy of your book is on display at a time, but several readers can be reading it at once.

  • Every new member receives one Starter Token after completing their profile.
  • Book details must match the real, published book. We may check listings before they appear.
  • Tokens cannot be bought, sold, transferred or exchanged for money, and they expire when your account is deleted.

8. International members

  • Amazon runs separate regional marketplaces. Each listing shows which platforms and marketplaces the author accepts.
  • Goodreads, Barnes & Noble and Kobo are good options if your Amazon marketplace doesn't match a listing.
  • ReviewCircle is free in every country — there are no prices, subscriptions or currency conversions.

9. When rules are broken

  • Depending on severity we may warn you, remove content, withhold Tokens, restrict features or suspend your account — always proportionately.
  • You can respond to any measure by writing to reviews@1ib.net.

Support 1IB on Social Media. We share about Productivity, Leadership, Business Development and Entrepreneurship.

Follow us on X